The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
Presented by: Catchment Players of Darebin
Venue: Banule Theatre - Viewbank College, Heidelberg
Reviewer: Emmalee Bell
Date Reviewed: Sunday 29th March 2009
 

The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee started its life as an improvised play, grew into a quirky off-Broadway musical and blossomed into a Tony Award-winning   show, attracting the award for Best Book of a Musical in 2005.  This production by Catchment Player of Darebin is the Victorian non-professional premiere and a smart choice of show for a company fighting for survival.  While it is not earth-shattering theatre, the endearing story of a group of dysfunctional primary school students competing in a spelling bee contest and simple one act format makes for an enjoyable evening (or afternoon as it was for me) at the theatre.  

The move from Darebin Arts Centre to the Banyule Theatre was a good one, not only financially, but artistically as well.  Already being a school auditorium, the scene was set the moment the audience walked into the venue.  The ambience was further heightened by an impressive effort to decorate the foyer in the theme of the show including Sesame Street music and children’s drawings. 

Directors Ang Cuy and Stuart Dodge have assembled a strong ensemble cast and should be commended for their seamless direction.  Simple productions such as Spelling Bee can be a trap for less skilful directors, appearing too static without the considered direction and fun choreography that Stuart and Ang utilised.  However, I did think that they were too subtle in their direction of Rona Lisa Peretti (Natasha Bassett) and Vice Principal Panch (Nathan Soutar).  Without an overt treatment of the interactions between the pair, some wonderful comic opportunities were underplayed and the “where are they now” finale didn’t make as much sense.

The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee is a character actors dream, with each performer getting the opportunity to sink their teeth into a highly stylised caricature with an obviously comic trait.  There is Chip Tolentino (Stephen Valeri) with his “unfortunate erection”, Logainne Schwartandgrubeniere (Helena Plazzer) with her lisp and overbearing gay fathers, Leaf Coneybear (Glen Barnett) with his comically short attention span,  William Barfee (Jenter Zilm) with his mucous disorder and magic foot spelling technique, Marcy Park (Lisa Pilkington) with her know-it-all demeanor, Olive Ostrovsky (Kate Burns) with her unnatural love of the dictionary, Mitch Mahoney (Blake Testro) with his tough approach to comfort counselling, Rona Lisa Peretti with her obsession for spelling bees and Vice Principal Panch with his scarily short fuse.  Each actor was both committed and well-suited to their roles creating a truly balanced ensemble cast with no evident weak-link or stand-out performance (although I must tell you to look out for Blake Testro’s hilarious portrayal of Logainne’s gay, Latino, father).

While William Finn’s songs are not vocally demanding, it is their lyrics that progress the story and diction needs to be spot on. In the opening number, “The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee” I found the diction a little bit sloppy and I also had trouble identifying which character was singing. However as the show progressed both issues settled and the performers all did a fantastic job of carrying their characterisations through their songs. 

The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee is a charming, light-hearted musical with a wide ranging appeal.  The cast are obviously enjoying themselves and they infect the audience with a sense of fun.    As it only runs until Sunday and the theatre has quite a small capacity, make sure you book to avoid disappointment.


Emmalee’s passion for musical theatre developed in her home-town of Warrnambool where she was in 18 productions before her 21st birthday.  After moving to Perth to complete an Arts Management degree at WAPPA, she performed in Les Miserables and the King and I at the Regent Theatre. Since moving to Melbourne in 2005, Emmalee performed in a concert production of Ragtime with Monash University Choral Society, played the Bakers Wife in Into the Woods (MD Productions), played Maria in The Sound of Music (Altona City Theatre), went incognito as a pit singer in Cats (CLOC), played Frauline Kost in Cabaret (ARC) and was in the Producers with Whitehorse Musical Theatre.  Emmalee is currently taking a break from performing while she concentrates on her real-life role as a marriage celebrant and fulfils her dream of travelling to New York in June. 

 

Back To Reviews